2023-24 MCCAA Awards Breakdown
| SPORT | ALL-REGION* | ALL-MCCAA | EASTERN CONFERENCE | WESTERN CONFERENCE | NORTHERN CONFERENCE | ALL-FRESHMAN |
| VOLLEYBALL | 18 | 5 E, 5 W, 5 N | 8 1st Team, 8 2nd Team | 8 1st Team, 8 2nd Team | 8 1st Team, 8 2nd Team | 6 each conf. |
| MEN'S XC | 10 | 18 | No Conference | No Conference | No Conference | 6 |
| WOMEN'S XC | 10 | 17 | No Conference | No Conference | No Conference | 6 |
| MEN'S SOCCER | 9 | 11 | No Conference | No Conference | No Conference | 6 |
| WOMEN'S SOCCER | 10 | 11 1st, 8 2nd | No Conference | No Conference | No Conference | 6 |
| MEN'S BOWLING | 6 | 8 | 6 | 6 | No Conference | 6 each conf. |
| WOMEN'S BOWLING | 6 | 8 | 6 | 6 | No Conference | 6 each conf. |
| MEN'S BASKETBALL | 23 | 6 E, 5 W, 6 N | 6 1st, 6 2nd, 6 3rd | 5 1st, 5 2nd, 5 3rd | 6 1st, 6 2nd, 6 3rd | 6 each conf. |
| WOMEN'S BASKETBALL | 23 | 6 E, 5 W, 6 N | 6 1st, 6 2nd, 6 3rd | 5, 1st, 5 2nd, 5 3rd | 6 1st, 6 2nd, 6 3rd | 6 each conf. |
| WRESTLING | 6 | 10 | No Conference | No Conference | No Conference | 6 |
| BASEBALL | 29 | 9 E, 9 W, 9 N | 10 1st, 10 2nd | 10 1st, 10 2nd | 10 1st, 10 2nd | 6 each conf |
| SOFTBALL | 28 | 9 E, 9 W, 9 N | 10 1st, 10 2nd | 10 1st, 10 2nd | 10 1st, 10 2nd | 6 each conf |
| GOLF | 5 | 10 | 10 | 6 | No Conference | 6 each conf |
* - Includes OCCAC and Independent (DIVISION II)
